Good afternoon,
My name is Janetta McKenzie and I am the director of the oil and gas program at the Pembina Institute. Thank you for your invitation to speak with you today about the present state and future potential for carbon capture and storage in Canada.
Carbon capture and storage is a proven technology to reduce greenhouse gas emissions at an industrial scale. It can be applied to many sectors that are otherwise difficult to reduce the carbon emissions from. These include oil and gas production, steel, cement, waste-to-energy incineration, blue hydrogen, and gas-fired electricity generation.
There are a small handful of CCS projects in operation in Canada today and a great deal more that are languishing on the drawing board for financial reasons.
I’m going to focus my remarks today on why that is. The obstacle to widespread deployment of carbon capture and storage in Canada is not a scientific problem or an engineering problem – it’s a political problem.
Specifically, it’s the unravelling of Canada’s industrial carbon pricing system.
Releasing carbon into the atmosphere creates real economic costs. Greenhouse gases are changing the climate, and that drives extreme wildfires, smoke, flooding, drought, violent storms, melting permafrost and rising sea levels. I’m sure many of you have constituents who experienced this first-hand.
If releasing carbon comes without any cost to the emitter, then no rational businessperson is going to spend their money to install and operate carbon capture and storage. Industrial carbon pricing is a way to attach a price in dollars to each tonne of carbon emissions, which reflects the real costs of climate change and creates an economic incentive to reduce emissions.
Let’s take a prominent example. The Pathways project is a proposal to capture carbon from several oil sands facilities and pipe it into underground spaces near Cold Lake, Alberta. When the oil sands companies first announced this plan in 2021, it was supposed to capture 68 million tonnes of carbon every year by 2041. Today, the current proposal is to capture only 16 million tonnes by 2045.
You can think of Pathways as a factory that makes carbon credits. The oil sands companies release about 100 million tonnes of carbon every year. Every tonne that Pathways can capture and store creates a credit that can be sold on the market. But a large new facility has a large price tag to build and to operate. The business case for Pathways rests on the effective price – the market price -- of the carbon credits it produces.
Carbon capture in the oilsands is a viable business when this price reaches about $130. Following the agreement signed by the Prime Minister and the Premier of Alberta earlier this year, we won’t see that $130 price until 2040.
Because there is no longer an investment mechanism to support the operation of carbon capture in the short term, Pathways is a quarter of the size and even more heavily subsidized by Canadian taxpayers. Meanwhile the companies that are benefiting from the emission of those 100 million tonnes of carbon every year are enjoying historic profits.
The weakening of industrial carbon pricing in Canada is also why the Swedish firm Varme has halted its plans for a waste-to-energy power station with carbon capture. It’s also why Heidelberg has paused its plans for a low-carbon cement plant.
Overall, we estimate that $40 billion in private sector industrial investment in Alberta is at risk due to this retreat on carbon pricing. That sends the investment, the employment, and the innovation elsewhere.
The market price of a carbon credit in Europe is more than $140 Canadian today. South Korea is investing $787 billion over the next nine years to decarbonize their industries. The carbon intensity of Canadian products will be a competitive disadvantage as we seek to diversify our trading relationships with jurisdictions – such as the European Union – that employ carbon border adjustment mechanisms.
In summary: carbon capture and storage is a growing global industry that can bring jobs and investment to Canada, and it will be the table stakes to participate in the global economy in the coming decade. Canada has a tremendous opportunity to take advantage of carbon capture and storage technologies, but we will lose that opportunity if we do not have a robust industrial carbon pricing system.
Thank you again for inviting me here and I would be happy to answer your questions.