Recommendations on QEC CIPP policy application

Recommendations on QEC CIPP policy applicationJoint briefing note to the Government of Nunavut

Publication - Sept. 15, 2020 - By Dave Lovekin, Marvin Quitoras, WWF-Canada, Nunavut Nukkiksautiit Corporation

first page of Joint briefing note to the Government of Nunavut

This briefing note was submitted by World Wildlife Fund Canada, Nunavut Nukkiksautiit Corporation and the Pembina Institute in response to the Qulliq Energy Corporation's Commercial Institutional Power Production (CIPP) policy proposal submitted to the Utility Rate Review Council May 2020.

While we appreciate QEC’s effort to develop this CIPP policy to attempt to reduce the reliance on diesel, the policy as laid out will do little to encourage the adoption of renewable energy systems in Nunavut and therefore contribute little to nothing to the Ikummatiit energy strategy or put Nunavut on a path of transition to renewable energy systems. As it currently stands, this CIPP policy may actually hinder local economic development and give allowance for non-Inuit companies to profit before Nunavut communities.

Recommendations around the CIPP policy

The Government of Nunavut should work with QEC on the following changes to the CIPP policy:

Promote Inuit ownership in renewable energy projects – This policy currently does not mandate any aspect of Inuit-led projects or the creation of local jobs and employment.
Develop community-specific PPA price – IPPs should be compensated at a varying rate depending on the variable costs in each community.
PPA rate should be much higher – The PPA rates should be increased to between $0.50 and $0.62 per kWh. A fair PPA rate would reflect cost savings to QEC, the GN and possibly the federal government including avoided operational and maintenance costs.
Include technical aspects – The policy should include “adders” for battery energy storage technologies, and must mandate grid reliability and define the interconnection process.

Complementary to this CIPP policy, the GN could offer rebates or incentives to support the capital investment necessary to develop these projects.

Other resources

First set of Pembina Institute recommendations (March 2019) to QEC to consider as they began developing their IPP policy
Pembina Institute response and further set of recommendations to the URRC on the CIPP portion of the QEC policy submission (July 2020)
Recommendations to the Government of Nunavut to accelerate clean energy projects offers seven recommendations on how to improve policies so that they can accelerate the development of Inuit-led clean energy projects (February 2022)

Tags: Provincial Policy, The North, Oil & Gas, Electricity, Renewable Energy, Indigenous Communities, Publications, Fair and inclusive rates, Nunavut

Related Publications

Cover of Independent Power Producer policy in Nunavut

Independent Power Producer policy in Nunavut Nunavut IODI champion and Pembina Institute feedback

Publication Oct. 31, 2022- By Alex Ittimangnaq, Dave Lovekin, Katarina Savic, Emily He

Delivery of the IPP policy in Nunavut has been slow, resulting in the delay of several renewable energy projects across the territory. The situation has created uncertainty for Inuit businesses, communities and developers who are ready to advance projects. This forthcoming policy must create clarity and certainty in addition to prioritizing Inuit-led projects.

Reexamining Rates for Remote Renewable Energy How integrating energy justice in power purchase agreements can accelerate an Indigenous-led clean energy transition

Publication June 7, 2023- By Arthur Bledsoe, Katarina Savic

In this paper, we consider the intersection of justice and energy with a special focus on the role of governments, regulators, and utilities in creating a fairer system of for power purchase agreements for Indigenous clean energy proponents. As part of the discussion, we interrogate the Bonbright Principles and their role in maintaining systemic barriers which directly affect the uptake of clean energy progress in remote Indigenous communities.

Cover of Recommendations on the forthcoming IPP Policy

Recommendations on the forthcoming IPP Policy To be presented to the Legislative Assembly of Nunavut

Publication Oct. 19, 2022- By Chris Severson-Baker, Dave Lovekin

Meeting the future energy needs of Nunavut’s growing population while also tackling climate change and the decarbonization of Nunavut’s energy systems will require a well-designed Independent Power Producer (IPP) Policy. The forthcoming IPP policy must match the speed and scale needed for the low-carbon energy transition, reduce the barriers to market entry for Inuit organizations, and prioritize Inuit ownership on renewable energy projects.