The Ontario Power Authority Supply Mix Report: A Review and Response

Publication - Feb. 27, 2006 - By Mark S. Winfield, Roger Peters, Matt Horne
Report
Download PDF

This document reviews the Supply Mix Advice Report released by the Ontario Power Authority in December 2005. The Power Authority recommended investments of up $83 billlion in new electricity supply in Ontario. The Pembina Institute's submission challenges many of the assumptions underlying the OPA's recommendations:

  • The OPA overestimates Ontario's likely rate of electricity load growth from 2005 to 2025;
  • The OPA underestimates the potential for electricity efficiency improvements to reduce demand for electricity;
  • The OPA underestimates Ontario's renewable energy supply potential;
  • The OPA underestimates the potential for cogeneration (combined heat and power plants) to assist in meeting electricity needs;
  • The OPA overestimates the cost and supply risks associated with the use of natural gas for electricity generation;
  • The OPA underestimates the environmental and economic costs and risks of nuclear power.
  • The overall methodology for assessing the environmental performance of supply options is fundamentally flawed, and the underlying analysis contains significant gaps.

The submission recommends that the future direction of the province's approach to electricity supply be the subject of a commission of inquiry or reviewed under Ontario's Environmental Assessment Act. A "no regrets" strategy of maximizing the development of renewable energy sources and the energy efficiency and productivity of Ontario's economy should be pursued in the meantime.

Tags:  Provincial Policy, Ontario, Electricity, Nuclear Power

Related Publications

Cover to Directing Decarbonization with deer striding between two wind turbines in a field with transmission lines in the background and mountains in the distance

Directing Decarbonization Examining regulatory barriers to a cleaner grid

Publication March 20, 2024- By Grace Brown, Lia Codrington
Canada's unique electricity system means there is no overarching federal body that oversees utility regulation. Provinces and territories manage their own systems. Report outlines regulatory challenges for grid decarbonization and provides case studies for making change.

Reexamining Rates for Remote Renewable Energy How integrating energy justice in power purchase agreements can accelerate an Indigenous-led clean energy transition

Publication June 7, 2023- By Arthur Bledsoe, Katarina Savic
In this paper, we consider the intersection of justice and energy with a special focus on the role of governments, regulators, and utilities in creating a fairer system of for power purchase agreements for Indigenous clean energy proponents. As part of the discussion, we interrogate the Bonbright Principles and their role in maintaining systemic barriers which directly affect the uptake of clean energy progress in remote Indigenous communities.
Cover of Exploring Ontario’s Pathways to Net-Zero Electricity

Exploring Ontario’s Pathways to Net-Zero Electricity Pembina Institute response to the IESO Pathways to Decarbonization report

Publication May 18, 2023- By Jason Wang, Binnu Jeyakumar
Provinces are making decisions that will have long-term consequences for the economy and the climate. The Ontario Independent Electricity System Operator has released a report considering power generation options and concluded that the province will continue to need natural gas to avoid rolling blackouts and an unreliable grid. Read our response to the report and recommendations that subsequent analysis include additional scenarios and greater inclusion of cheaper renewables in the energy mix.

Subscribe

Our perspectives to your inbox.

The Pembina Institute endeavors to maintain your privacy and protect the confidentiality of any personal information that you may give us. We do not sell, share, rent or otherwise disseminate personal information. Read our full privacy policy.